shakes wrote:
Ugueth Will Shiv You wrote:
shakes wrote:
lesson went well, till it didn't. Got rid of the shanks and was hitting the 9 and 7 iron great, then he got me to hinge my wrists on takeaway to give me a bigger backswing and more distance. It worked great at first. Then we moved to the 5 iron and it was shank city again. Then tried the hybrid, put some tape on the face to see where contact was and no matter what I did I couldn't avoid hitting the ball with the hozzle.
You were probably told this by your pro, but the shanks (believe it or not) are easy to get rid of as long as you understand why it's happening. Luckily for you -- a person who has played hockey -- this is a swing flaw that you can fix pronto.
Your hands are getting further away from your body. Period.
More often than not, this is due to the clubhead dropping behind your body. This is a tough concept to explain in words, so here are two videos that have helped me immensely over the years:
David Leadbetter's take on a drill to cure the shanks:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y9JvY8-vQ4AMike Malaska's overall concept of feeling the clubhead in front of your body (also references the slapshot feeling):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BCvsCUGVeB0I'll check those out later today. My issue has always been that my first move to the ball is with my head which in turn changes the angle of attack and causes me to dive at the ball and hit it with the hozzle. I Fixed it in previous years by going exclusively to an outside in swing where I was actively trying to move the hozzle away from the ball. It works but it gives me a weak fade which is far from ideal. This year I committed to an inside out swing and trying to hit a draw which apparently has brought the hozzle back in play. But this only started out of the blue a couple weeks ago and wasn't having any problems with shanks until then.
This exact progression happened to me, too. Started shanking, went to an outside-to-in swing, lost distance, when back to inside-to-in swing, started shanking.
I promise you can fix this really, really easily. It'll take a little practice, but as long as you get that clubhead out in front of your body more, you'll be cookin' with gas.
This is what's happening to your swing when I say that the clubhead is "getting behind your body." The picture below shows the clubhead beginning to drop back behind the golfer's body, which causes the hands to get too far out in front. Pure physics and gravity cause your hands to move away from your body in an effort to give yourself room to swing the club through.

Physically, and because you've played sports before and have good hand-eye coordination, the only way your body can make an athletic move to make contact with the ball is to move your arms out and away from your body.