long time guy wrote:
Seacrest wrote:
long time guy wrote:
denisdman wrote:
Baby, that was my point above. Folks have used religious beliefs and texts to justify all sorts of behavior throughout history.
I don't believe the Muslim Terrorists have any interest in religion at all. They are merely using it as an excuse to gather power, territory, and a rational to attract followers.
No truly religious person could ever justify killing innocent people. And it's one thing to kill people in war where both sides have soldiers trained for battle and quite another to help suicide bombers kill patrons of a cafe.
The spin on Christianity being somehow the more nobler of religions doesn't jive either. The Protestants had to leave Europe because of religious persecution. You substitute the word heretic for infidel and you won't find much of a distinction.
If you don't think the actions and requirements of Christ are more noble then those of Mohammed and Islam, then you should probably change the subject now.
Substitute "Love one another" for "Kill the infidels" and even the most thick headed can see an obvious difference.
You unwillingness to accept the actions of the prophet is belied by the fact that most Muslims do.
If Christianity is the more nobler of religions then why have acts conducted because of "god's preordainment" occurred through out the history of the U.S.? You really do seem to gloss over the actions of the U.S. in all of this.
I have essentially provided evidence as to the Genesis of the modern day conflict yet you keep with the religious aspect.
I'm not really interested in fighting religious arguments. They don't correlate with the historical/political at all. I'm not arguing that Islam is moral or immoral. I'm stating that the political and military actions of the U.S. has caused middle easterners to perform terrorist acts against the U.S. there has not been one point made which refutes this either.
The propaganda surrounding religion is just that, propaganda. It is constructed by Americans to absolve guilt. Libya wasn't invaded because Quaddafi was a religious fundamentalist. Iraq wasn't invaded because Hussein was an Islamic terrorist. Mossadegh wasn't overthrown because he was running around yelling Allah u akbar or some other bullshit.
You want to find commonality here it is. They all were in possession of large oil reserves. Post WWII U.S. foreign policy in the Middle East has been driven by possessing Middle Eastern oil. Religious religious differences have played virtually no role. People in the region understand this. Why do you think Hussein set fire to them during the first Gulf War?
This spin about culture and religion is just spin and it prays upon the ignorance of people too disinterested to ever Crack a book about the subject. The first Gulf War nor 9/11 wasn't the beginning of U.S. Middle Eastern relations, but for a number of people in this country apparently it was.
Here is your original statement:
long time guy wrote:
The crux of the problem lie in the tendency to generalize. Not all Muslims are radical and not all Muslims wish death upon the West. Islam was not conceived as a religion that targets the West either. The West became a target once they began to interfere in their politics.
I find it ironic that the United States can drop bombs in their countries, plant troops on the ground in their countries, overthrow leaders and attempt to impose U.S. styled govermnents yet Muslims are the radical ones.
A couple of things. Your assessment that Islam was not started to attack the west is patently false. So you changed direction to Iraq. After i pointed out that we didn't indiscriminately pick Afghanistan as a target.
So, I think we can agree that the US never belonged in Iran. I think we can also agree that we didn't belong in either war in the Middle East either. Furthermore, I hope we can agree that a discussion of facts is helpful to those who are interested in learning and don't have time to crack a book.
Finally, I'm not looking to spin anything. I have stated clearly we should discuss the failings of Christianity as well. I have thanked you in the past for your willingness to discuss and enlighten the board to things unknown. I hope it continues.
_________________
Joe Orr Road Rod wrote:
The victims are the American People and the Republic itself.