“Dude, leave me alone!” she said as she pulled out her firearm. (While MTV cameras did not show Evans brandishing the handgun, they did show a black screen reading, “At this point, Jenelle pulled out her firearm.”)

Evans did not immediately respond to PEOPLE’s request for comment.

She escaped as she raced back to the main road, telling Eason the other driver was following her.

“Well, don’t f—— god d--- follow him!” Eason yelled at her through the speakerphone. “You call the police, you don’t follow people.”

As Evans ended the conversation, she called MTV producer Kristen to explain the situation. As she did so, a police car pulled her over.

“Dude, please come, now I’m being pulled over because I called the cops and the guy called the cops,” she told Kristen as she began to cry.