Not far from Chillicothe (Chalahgawtha to the Shawnee?). Stan Lee used to name-check Chillicothe--where in the real/non-Marvel world women keep getting murdered / go missing at a surprisingly high rate for a podunk Ohio town.
Southern Ohio stretching toward Kentucky/West Virginia = Shawnee territory. Whole damn area is cursed.
Wonder if the Wagner family patriarch gets any royalties for being the life-model for Mr Potato Head:
That's one crazy attempt at ADR in lieu of family court. Both Wagner grandmas involved in covering up the murders.
Police up in Wisco trying to sort out the Closs family murder/abduction of the daughter should harvest some DNA from the daughter's hair/toothbrush and compare it to the deceased father's. Possible Denise Closs/the mother stepped out on James and Jayme/the daughter resulted and mom kept it to herself. The kid's real father runs across pics of Jayme on social media years later and sees himself in the kid; does the usual math and maybe goes to confront the mom about it. Mom pulls a gun to chase other-dad-dude off, dude wrestles gun away, caps mom-n-dad and takes off with Jayme. Far-fetched, but Barron PD appear clueless about what happened.