Yeah. I'd have Oscar top 5 .. bump Bird down a few notches, Hakeem up. Shaq n Lebron are top 12 .. Lebron needs to kick some ass for a few more years to be top 5.

Brian Shaw is ranked much too high on 312player's list.

Where is Dirk?

17th. Not sure I agree with having Malone being at 16 ahead of both him and Barkley.

lebron has made 5 finals in a row in the salary cap era, that's pretty damn impressive.

Yeah. I'd have Oscar top 5 .. bump Bird down a few notches, Hakeem up. Shaq n Lebron are top 12 .. Lebron needs to kick some ass for a few more years to be top 5.

Isaiah Thomas was better than Scottie Pippen, John Stockton, Steph Curry, and David Robinson. They shouldn't not be rated above him on this list.

Isaiah Thomas was better than Scottie Pippen, John Stockton, Steph Curry, and David Robinson. They shouldn't not be rated above him on this list.

I'm not sure how you can say a great player who is 5'10" is better than a great player who is 7'0" though.

What do you mean by this? If the 5'10" player impacts the game more, he's better.

That's really subjective. We're talking about two of the greatest players ever. Obviously the seven footer is capable of impacting the game more. Kobe can hog the ball like a goof and impact the game more than Shaq but that doesn't mean he was a better player. In the post-Jordan years the big man has become unfairly maligned and dismissed with shit like "he's just big". It's no different than saying Curry "can just shoot".

Isaiah Thomas was the best player on a team that won two championships and was an injury away from winning a third. Robinson had a reputation for coming up small in the playoffs. He only became a winner once Duncan came aboard. Thomas's teams also had to go through the Celtics and Lakers to win championships. Even During Robinson's best season, his MVP season, he was thoroughly outplayed during the playoffs by Olajuwon. Thomas dominated every guard he matched up against aside from Magic. The size difference necessitated that he couldn't guard Magic. He beat Boston and L.A. without the benefit of having great players on his team. Pat Riley once suggested that for about a Four year stretch he provided some of the best point guard play that the NBA has ever seen.

Isaiah Thomas was better than Scottie Pippen, John Stockton, Steph Curry, and David Robinson. They shouldn't not be rated above him on this list.

Agreed, he's a top 20 player all time..the others are not. Where do you think A.I. should be ranked?,



Curry could be top 10 in 12 years, too early to say.

Agreed, he's a top 20 player all time..the others are not. Where do you think A.I. should be ranked?,



Curry could be top 10 in 12 years, too early to say.

That's really subjective. We're talking about two of the greatest players ever. Obviously the seven footer is capable of impacting the game more. Kobe can hog the ball like a goof and impact the game more than Shaq but that doesn't mean he was a better player. In the post-Jordan years the big man has become unfairly maligned and dismissed with shit like "he's just big". It's no different than saying Curry "can just shoot".