I feel like Rick started this thread so he could have something to do (argue) at work today.

Staubach
Marino
Brady
Montana
With another 2-3 seasons, Rodgers

Elway & Manning dominate the top of my "most overloved" list though.

How does Marino make that list?

Well, now that Denny is ignoring my posts because I'm an asshole I have to do something.

Because he was the best passer I've ever seen. And he played with avg talent on the field & poor off. coordinators.

Marino was Manning before the NFL made it easy for QBs and offenses. Unlike Manning he did it with less.

I'm not sure how any objective person can look at the receivers in Denver and say Manning made them better. Everyone except Thomas was already considered great/good.

I'm a big dumb shitlib baby

Playoff QB Rating


1. Bart Starr+ 104.8 1956-1971 gnb
2. Aaron Rodgers (31) 103.1 2005-2014 gnb
3. Kurt Warner 102.8 1998-2009 2TM
4. Drew Brees (35) 100.7 2001-2014 2TM
5. Joe Montana+ 95.6 1979-1994 2TM
6. Mark Sanchez (28) 94.3 2009-2014 nyj
7. Ken Anderson 93.5 1971-1986 cin
8. Joe Theismann 91.4 1974-1985 was
9. Eli Manning (33) 89.3 2004-2014 nyg
10. Peyton Manning (38) 89.2 1998-2014 2TM
11. Troy Aikman+ 88.3 1989-2000 dal
12. Tom Brady (37) 87.5 2000-2014 nwe
13. Colin Kaepernick (27) 87.3 2011-2014 sfo
14. Brett Favre 86.3 1991-2010 2TM
15. Joe Flacco (29) 86.2 2008-2014 rav
16. Steve Young+ 85.8 1985-1999 sfo
17. Philip Rivers (33) 85.2 2004-2014 sdg
Matt Ryan (29) 85.2 2008-2014 atl
19. Warren Moon+ 84.9 1984-2000 2TM
20. Jay Cutler 84.8 2010 fompfompfomp

It's more fun to be a victim

There will never be an effective vaccine. I'll never get one anyway.

Rick is correct. What Manning has done is nothing short of remarkable. It's never been done to the level he has done it with a new team.

Manning is extremely underrated and people tend to overemphasize his playoff record (even though he has 1 ring and 2 SB appearances) . Those QB's who have multiple SB wins have experienced a lot of luck themselves too. Brady has played for the most stable franchise in the NFL over his career.

Elway is the most overrated QB in NFL history. He was Jay Cutler until he won 2 SB's at the end on the back of Terrell Davis.

I have MANY years of experience in trying to appreciate steaming piles of dogshit.

I'm a big dumb shitlib baby

I am thinking that Tebow made them this way, before Manning got there. I am sure Brick will agree.

I'm not sure how any objective person can look at the receivers in Denver and say Manning made them better. Everyone except Thomas was already considered great/good.

Come on??? You are seriously going to call Elway Cutler before the superbowls?

That is just football stupid.

Demaryius Thomas even looked good with Tebow. We all knew he just needed an average QB to look great. We s Welker was already a stud. Sanders was pretty good too. Julius Thomas is the only one who wasn't.

Emmanuel Sanders is already almost at his career highs and that is only 7 games in. Demariyus Thomas more than double his career highs as soon as Peyton got there. Julius Thomas virtually didn't exist in the NFL prior to Manning. Erik Decker had two career years with Manning.

Come on??? You are seriously going to call Elway Cutler before the superbowls?

That is just football stupid.

I'm a big dumb shitlib baby

Peyton throws the ball a lot. Is that surprising? I believe last I looked Demaryius had a higher yards per catch average with Tebow and hadn't played more than 10 games in his career with shitty to mediocre QBs.

Are you honestly arguing that Peyton doesn't make WR's significantly better?

He's the luckiest guy in NFL history that he happened to play with so many players who just happened to have career years with him throwing the ball.

I'm a big dumb shitlib baby

I have MANY years of experience in trying to appreciate steaming piles of dogshit.

Staubach
Marino
Brady
Montana
With another 2-3 seasons, Rodgers

Elway & Manning dominate the top of my "most overloved" list though.

If you hate Laurence, then don't listen - don't comment. When he co-hosts the B&B show, take that day off ... listen to an old podcast of a Bernstein solo show and jerk off all day.

So many Elway haters. I feel sorry for all of you.

John Elway is literally the worst person in the history of sports. I hope he gets ebola.

If you hate Laurence, then don't listen - don't comment. When he co-hosts the B&B show, take that day off ... listen to an old podcast of a Bernstein solo show and jerk off all day.

Glad there's someone else here who has Marino ahead of Elway. Elway consistently being regarded as an obvious top 5 quarterback is rubbish and I hope gets seriously reevaluated one day.