rogers park bryan wrote:
Regular Reader wrote:
He really didn't need much more than to compare the 1990 seasons of Bob Welch (Cy Young winner) and Dave Stewart (who was the unquestioned ace of that A's staff). Smoke took on the Ace of the other team, had generally better numbers and was far, far more the feared pitcher. IIRC, Welch had the far better W/L record, but he often got his shit knocked all around (or out in Oakland
) the park
Another reason why pitching wins cant be trusted over a small sample size.
Even if you believe its pitcher vs pitcher, its not equal. One guy might face Bumgarner 4 times and another guy gets three shots at Edwin Jackson
That's true, but we can look at that.
Bob Welch had a great year in 1990 no matter how you slice it. He was also pretty good in 1977 when he released
French Kiss with the hits "Sentimental Lady" and "Ebony Eyes".