FavreFan wrote:
long time guy wrote:
Boilermaker Rick wrote:
long time guy wrote:
I will conclude it with this little nugget. You used team success with Marshall and Anthony as a measure of their value as players. You didn't use the same system when assessing Davis's worth as a player. Davis is being measured on his individual abilities whereas the other two guys were measured based largely on the success of their respective teams. That is it in a nutshell. You can argue that Davis needs more time but I'm arguing that if he is a top five player he should at least make the playoffs. I'm not suggesting championships. Just playoffs. He has enough talent to get it done if he is that good.
I said I'm not judging a 22 year old. That was it. I didn't say anything else about Davis. If he equals Carmelo in terms of playoff success I'll say the exact same things about him.
Don't make me call the Scorehead rule on you a second time today.
He will be 23 in less than two months and you want to know the last guy in which the "He is only 23 Yrs old" argument was used? Lance Stephenson. I rest my case
You really are all over the place today. Some of us(pretty sure Rick is not included here) thought Lance would improve and become a great player. He never did. Anthony Davis has already submitted one of the 20 best statistical seasons of all time. They are not comparable in any sort of fashion. I respect that you watch a lot of games and I am trying to take your NBA posts seriously, but when you have really awful posts like this you make my job a lot more difficult. Help me help you.
The it's too early argument was used in favor of him also. It really wasn't. Davis is a better player but being a good player and a winning player are two different things. Davis has been compared to guys like Duncan and it rarely gets refuted. He needs to impact games more if that is going to be the case.
Once again why is team 50 games under .500 if he is that good? The Melo bashing has been constant yet the guy has been over.500 since he entered the league. There is blatant hypocrisy during this entire argument.
It's a little presumptuous to suggest that his teams will get better simply because he ages. That seems to be the argument here and it's false.
_________________
The Hawk wrote:
This is going to reach a head pretty soon.