Joe Orr Road Rod wrote:
rogers park bryan wrote:
Joe Orr Road Rod wrote:
312player wrote:
Reminds me of Kevin Mitchell, I'd trade him for pitching in a heartbeat.
Not a bad comp.
Ill take an MVP who catches balls bare handed
I'm looking at him now and he was a lot better than I remembered. A lot of big numbers in that era.
It's not such a great comp after all. No way do I believe Schwarber is going to finish his career with a 142 OPS+. Stairs is a better comp.
If Stairs is your comp, the Cubs fans are going to be watching a lot of bombs fly off Schwarber's bat for the next decade plus. Stairs ended up with 265 career jacks. Not an overwhelming number, but a pretty impressive total when you realize he didn't receive 400+ plate appearances in the bigs until his age 29 season. Conventional wisdom is that a player peaks at 27 so Stairs played his best seasons in the minors.
Schwarber still has his 23-28 year old seasons to play with the Cubs, again, a few of those should be his best seasons. Schwarber banged out 16 bombs last year. Stairs hammered 27, 26, 38, and 21 jacks in his 29-32 seasons, probably the best proxy for Schwarbers mid twenty seasons. That's an average of 28 dingers per year. Lets just drop it to 25 for the fun of it. That gives Schwarber 166 jacks for his age 22-28 seasons, and when we tack on the 265 Staris jacks, you're looking at 431 career bombs.
Yeah, I'll take that. Also not for nothing Stairs also had a career .356 OBP, again, without the benefit of his peak seasons.
Granted Schwarber is going to give a bunch of value back in the field assuming he doesn't make some impressive strides.
The 431 bombs, puts him in Konerko territory, and I'd venture to say that is a better comp if Schwarber ever could make it to 1b, most likely his natural position.
Also, just looking at the numbers your Mitchell/Stairs comp is closer than you think. Mitchell had the advantage of playing all of his peak years in the majors, again, Stairs burned them up in the minors. From the ages of 29-32 Mitchell had a WAR of 9.3, Stairs, 6.9. So although Mitchell was better, it wasn't the chasm that you might think.