good dolphin wrote:
The problem with blindly supporting A Plan is that in copying the Cubs, there is no recognition that the Cubs got incredibly lucky with throw in players who became cornerstone pieces of the championship. So A Plan boils down to trade Sale and pray for luck as opposed to keeping Sale and relying on your player development...I just upset myself with that sentence.
Cubs turned relative turds into gold by trading for players with upside. Those players realizing that upside can be credited however you want. If the guys the Cubs trade people like Feldman for never turn into Cy Young winners, its not really a surprise because Feldman wasn't that great to begin with.
The Sox need to turn gold into more gold. It has nothing to do with luck. It has everything to do with doing competent evaluations of players you are trading for. If the guys the Sox traded Sale for never pan out, that isn't luck. It's bad judgement. It would be different with a shiny turd like Frazier. But blowing a trade of Sale, Quintana, Eaton, and, to a lesser extent, Abreu is just a failure of Hahn and Kenny to evaluate players.