Yeah, she let Hollywood ruin her. Terrible parents didn't help either.

_________________

Bingo. I never thought Lindsay Lohan was anything more than mildly attractive, and I've heard people say that in Mean Girls, she's the hottest chick they've ever seen. There were probably 4 or 5 in that cast that I would have taken over her. Maybe it's just that some of us don't like the ginger look.

_________________

Nobody put a gun to her head, she decided to drink heavy, pop pills, smoke cigarettes. She's actually a Muslim now.

_________________

I think I started that hot/ugly chick threat, but I can't find it. Maybe it got pruned with the babes section.

_________________

I'm sure she popped some pills, but it was widely reported she liked the smell of yay.

_________________

4 or 5? Cmon now. Who?

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0377092/

_________________

Rachel McAdams, Lizzy Kaplan, and Lacey Chabert just for starters (and all three easily before Lohan for me).

I also thought Jaime Pressley was in that? She would have been number four, but maybe I'm thinking of a different movie.

_________________

Tina fey and Amanda Seyfried too.

_________________

Seyfried for sure. Not so sure on Fey.

_________________

Are we talking 2004 Lizzy Caplan? You spoke in past tense, so I assumed you meant women who appeared to be remotely attractive back then.

_________________

Yeah, but come on... she was intentionally made to look like a goth weirdo in that movie. She still looked good back then.

_________________

Caplan's peak was Cloverfield, which is a very underrated movie. One of my all-time favorites.

_________________

So all 3 of these women plus Rachel McAdams...



Over 2004 Lindsay Lohan?

_________________

Yup. Not a fan of the ginger redheads.

_________________

Cloverfield is great. Not that underrated tho. RT has it at 77%...

She was pretty good in the terrible "Now You See Me 2". Also, not bad with her small role in "The Interview".

_________________

_________________

McAdams and Chabret for sure.. But Lohan overruled my anti ginger bias in that movie to be three. Seyfried.. No.. Don't get it.. I also don't get the Lizzy Kaplan love in that movie or anything else I've seen her in.

I have an unusual fetish for Lizzy Caplan. There's just something about her. I realize it's not popular opinion.

_________________

Seyfried is #1 IMO

_________________

Everyone has one of those that they elevate from a 5 to an 8 or whatever for some reason. No, I'm not calling Caplan a 5 I'm just saying everyone has that one person or two they elevate for some reason.

Hot enough

_________________

She looked good in Superbad and easy a when she was thicker

_________________
I am the liquor Randy

Her peak was Season 1 of Masters of Sex.

I didn't even know who she was before that. I do now.

_________________
You know me like that.

I liked her in that show where she was one of three Italian sisters. Jennifer Esposito was the oldest and that Sanchez chick was in there too. All hot.

_________________
Anybody here seen my old friend Bobby?
Can you tell me where he's gone?
I thought I saw him walkin' up to The Hill
With Elon, Tulsi, and Don

I get a kick out of hot chicks who can play counterculture/trashy well. Caplan does that. She's never the popular or most sought after girl/woman. She's always the one that is trashy hot and that you could probably convince to go in the bathroom with you during a party.

If she ever played a lead "princess" type role, I would lose all interest.

_________________

She's one of those actresses who might as well be the same person. Her, a couple of girls names Olivia, an Emily or two, a Kristen somebody...

_________________

Emma Stone is objectively hot but I don't feel anything. Not like Emmy Rossum or Winona Ryder.

_________________

I remember that show. Had to look it up, Related. I was a fan of Sanchez and Esposito in that show. Didn't have a recollection of a Caplan. My first known exposure to Caplan was masters of sex as well even in retrospect I'd seen her a lot. That might say something.

I actually disagree that she's objectively hot. There are some I'd give that "title" to, but not her. She is unique and, to me, not in a good way.

_________________

A girl I used to hang out with looks kind of like her. Of course she has about 20 years on Stone.

_________________
Anybody here seen my old friend Bobby?
Can you tell me where he's gone?
I thought I saw him walkin' up to The Hill
With Elon, Tulsi, and Don