RFDC wrote:
pittmike wrote:
W&S had a tape today of Maddon admitting he lied during the playoffs that the coaches were great or safe. Didn’t want to upset the room during the series.
That was a no win situation for Maddon.
What can he say there? Yeah I am cleaning house as soon as we are out? He did all he could do with that situation.
The question isn't what can he say, but what can't he say or what shouldn't he say.
He can't say that he is thinking of cleaning house. That I agree with.
To say he did all he could is completely wrong. Ten days ago, he spoke in glowing terms of his staff;
Quote:
"The staff has done a great job," Maddon said Wednesday. "Our staff has been awesome, and they're tight, a tightly knit group. There's a lot of synergy involved. No one knows everything. Everybody helps everybody. There's cross-pollination. Nobody is on their own little island. I like that."
"(They don't withhold) saying something to me that they have on their mind, which I really appreciate," Maddon said. "They don't feel like they can't say it, and that's one thing I wanted to build, that kind of method. Don't hold back. Just say it. You know you can. There's nothing held against you for doing it. There are some places that is the case."
He should not have said that. Actually, he can't say that without a boatload of backlash. Maddon is deserving of every piece of criticism he is getting right now. This is all his own fault.
It has become a no win situation for Maddon because of what he said. He should have given a non answer answer...something to the effect of "My coaching staff has won a lot of games for me, and right now they are doing the best they can to prep the guys to try and extend this NLCS. There is a time and place to talk about offseason moves, and this is not it." If he says that its done and over with. Instead he had to act like the smartest guy in the room again and in retrospect sounded like a total idiot. There is simply no defending him here. Take off your Cubs colored glasses for a minute and try to look at the situation logically.
_________________
Joe Orr Road Rod wrote:
It's more fun to be a victim
Caller Bob wrote:
There will never be an effective vaccine. I'll never get one anyway.