long time guy wrote:
FavreFan wrote:
I wouldn't take that bet. Butler has been better than Irving the last several years, but Kyrie is having a career year so far and his teammates are better than Butler's and he's in a worse conference so he's easily gonna have the better team record, which significantly impacts votes like this.
There's still a lot of season left to play though. Butler's December numbers are awesome. It'll be interesting to see how the rest of the year plays out.
Kyrie Irving is playing with two unproven players and a guy (Horford) that Boston fans wanted to run out of town last year. Kyrie IRving has always been better than Jimmy BUtler. It didn't take playing for Boston. When they played on the Olympic team that was thinking. When he made his first All Star team that was the thinking. It is the thinking right now. He will be in the Hall of Fame barring injury. If not for the injury which made him miss 2-3 months a few years back he'd be on his 6th All Star game in 7 Seven years right now.
He is simply better and has been since he entered the league.
Imu stated that very few believe me then stated that he wouldn't take the bet because a substantial number believed me.
Look at the analytics that you love so much. I'm sure he is being murdered there also. The weaker conf. Argument is one of the primary reasons Butler made the All Star game.
It doesn't matter which conf with All NBA either.
I did. Kyrie is slightly ahead this year. Butler holds a commanding lead over him the last couple years and for their careers. As I said, Butler has been better recently. He got off to a poor start this season so Kyrie is slightly ahead stat wise(Kyrie is also having a damn good year himself, a career year).
It seems like you can't get straight which criteria you want to use. You change it daily depending on the argument. Is it All Star game appearances(Sorry but this is still a laughably stupid and primitive way to evaluate players). Is it All NBA teams?(Kyrie doesn't have an advantage there). Is it stats? Is it the eye test?
And yes, which conference you play in does affect how easy it is for you to make an All NBA team. Those teams take team record heavily into account, so if you are in a conference where it is easier to win games it's going to be easier to make an All NBA team.
Kyrie Irving will also be top 5 in MVP voting this year. Has Butler ever placed anywhere at any point of his career?
Let's play the "analytics" game. Kyrie kills him there also.
Kyrie also is playing with the 2nd best player on the team. His team still has the best record in the league. No other player on their team will be an All Star either.
Fact is he is simply better and this season leaves no doubt. If he'd gotten away from James sooner it would have been become apparent much sooner. He was always better. This isn't anything new. Maybe to you and other posters on here thought it even during the summer. The majority that posted as I recall.
Much like Giannis you simply got it wrong and rather than admit it you're placing a number of variables in your evaluation.