Frank Coztansa wrote:
denisdman wrote:
If you followed my posts over the years, you know I care deeply about education. Rick and I have debated quite a bit as we have different feelings on the matter but both want the same outcome.
It's not just edumacation, it has to be the right education.
What the fuck are you going to do with a major like "great books"? Unless you go to law school, teaching, or you're that hot chick from Pawn Stars, you're going to end up in sales or some mundane office job for $30K a year.
Nothing wrong with a trade- like your automotive field sibling- as secondary education either.
See I disagree with this a bit Frank and here would be my points.
I am just believer that education has inherent value in itself. If a 19 year old is at a rigorous academic institution and studying "great books" and putting in the requisite effort and learning the subject matter, I think that has intrinsic value. The human brain is still in a developmental stage into the early 20s, so you're feeding and developing a growing brain, that is going to have lifelong positive results.
That said, someone who studies "great books" as a major should be aware that they are likely going to take a much less glamorous and low paying initial job than someone with a more vocational major. They are going to start off behind a lot of their peers. The key though is that degree allows them a path to promotion from that initial job that someone without that degree could not access. My brother is quite successful in his career and his major has nothing to do at all with his current job. Now he had to work a lot of years at some suck ass jobs, but that is just how it goes.