Puckhead wrote:
Sure, I do wish and think they can do both.
Hendry is a good GM who has been the unfortunate beneficiary of players that have never panned out to their potential in either the later portion of September or early portion of October. Not to bring up bad memories, but 03 was the year. He was the guy that turned Bobby Hill into Aramis Rameriz and Kenny Loften. In 2004, he was the one to turn Hee Soep Choi into Derrick Lee. in 07, he brought in Soriano as one of the top 5 highest paid contracts in baseball. He brought in Baker, a proven winner in San Fran. He brought in Pinella, a proven winner. Unfortunately, the players in the end of failed him.
BUT, he may no longer be the right man for the job if he cannot get the ownership to spend. If that is the case, you have to get a GM who can focus and improve whatever the problem is with talent evaluation and scouting of position players. Hendry has started to make improvements by placing the right people in positions to evaluate talent. Have you noticed one huge change over the past few years that doesnt get talked about much? Remember when Baker used to complain about how advanced scouting didnt prepare the players to face pitchers they havent seen before? I remember at least a few times where the Cubs got shut out by some random pitcher and that comment had been spewed. Now, it may be that Pinella just doesnt talk about that kind of stuff, but the Cubs rocked pitchers over the last year and a half. The key is that they beat up on a pitcher during an inning. Thats advanced scouting for you when you see an entire lineup bat around because they see something in either the pitchers delivery or their mode of operation out on the mound and every player is aware of it.
Hendry isn't one of the worst GM's in the league but he isn't one of the best either. I agree that early in his tenure he made some great moves. His best was dumping Todd Hundley for Grudz and Karros. My problem with Hendry is he hasn't made many more moves like this. Unless Hendry can send a prospect to a team reducing payroll or Hendry is trying to reduce payroll himself, Hendry probably isn't making the trade.
As for the prospects not producing, those are Hendry's guys. Hendry was Assistant GM/Minor League Director until took over as GM in 2002. Guys like Patterson, Pie, Orie, Ryan Harvey, and Brian Dopirak are Hendry's guys. That's not to take away from Hendry being involved in drafting pitchers like Wood, Prior, Garland, and Zambrano among others. But Hendry and crew have really struggled drafting position players. That being said, he did hire Tim Wilken from the Blue Jays, who is highly regarded as a scout. So I'm hoping he can help.
And I know I said Prior was a good draft pick. I still stand by it. Nobody knew what he would become what he has. It's too bad the Twins didn't take Prior and the Cubs could've had Joe Mauer.