bigfan wrote:
Tried to order from this place in the past....twice. Once told not taking any more orders and the other times was a 90 minute wait to pick up a pizza, so didnt make the move.
If you are not familiar with the Great Lake, they got some best pizza in the country award from Food and Whhine in 2009? They maintain that chabby chic storefont look, with 2 or 3 tables that look like from the french chateau (Guessing just a renovated 2 flat door made into a table)
The Menu is like 3 different options of pizza, only 1 is Tomato..and the menu I saw did offer Pepperoni..which I was surprised, due to knowing they offered very limited topping...a few mushrooms, cheese, onions and basil.
Anyways, was in the area tonight, due to a meeting and placed my order...and got the 1 hour wait time...perfect...Meeting should take an hour.
Ordered a cheese and pepperoni. Was told they didnt have pepperoni, but they did have Chorizo..."it's a spicy mexican sausage" (Yeah, I know what it is culinary queen.)
14", thin crust pizza, on a stone, probably took 3 minutes to make and 5 minutes to cook....$32! Well now...this better be some good pizza!
No way I am waiting to drive home before a sample slice comes out!
Yeah, it's good. A Little greasy as they add Olive Oil to the finished product, which I dont think they need to do, but what do I know, I have only been eating pizza since this guy was crapping in his diapers. It was not the Mona Lisa of Pizza as they sure think it is...and the 4 patrons in the joint...all wearing black, as they are out for a special night...of pizza....while having the waitress bring them gourmet truffles in a container to see which one they should by...I mean they are at Great Lake!
The Pizza is good. Crispy thin crust, cheese melted..but very limited amount (I am sure the pizza master would tell you it is the perfect amount) and the chorizo was ok as well, nothing special.
Would I order again if it was closer and cheaper, sure. It was a little like an appetizer pizza at a nicer place.
Pizza Serio gives you almost the same thing, for half the price and half the pretentiousness from this overpriced, overhyped Andersonville place.
No knock on the product, but $32..come on son!
I think I had a similar review about a year ago.
It's a good pizza. It's not some orgasmic experience worthy of enduring shoddy treatment, high prices and unnecessarily long wait times.
I went in on a week day night towards the end of the day so I didn't have to wait long.
Ownership could best be described as the offspring of a three way between the soup Nazi, an underground music store owner and a university of chicago coffee shop barrista. You are treated with disdain from the moment you order, knowing that you will profane their artwork with your burgiouse tastebuds.
I'd like to say I'm not a fan of the "artisan"/"small batch" movement for everyday foods in this city. I kind of like it to tell you the truth. However, ownership seems to be populated by douchebags of the first order. I would think you would love what you do if you decided to open a shop. Part of what you do is sharing it with the world. These people seem only devoted to making some philosphical ideal food item, never to be eaten, only to be displayed to shame all the others who call themselves that food item.