shakes wrote:
As usual, idiotic attempts at logic from BR. Tyson was going to follow Rob's plan. Tyson had a convo with Russell where Russell convinced him to vote for Parvati instead. Tyson goes to tribal and does exactly what Russell tells him to do. Tyson goes home. Boilermaker Rick claims that Russell had nothing to do with this?
Russell said he was voting for Parvati. He probably said that to others 10 other times in the season. So yes, Russell did have something to do with it but that was entirely a mistake by Tyson. It's not a strategy to tell someone else on the other side a lie and then for that person to make a stupid decision. I can't give credit to Russell for being the beneficiary of one of the dumbest plays in Survivor history. You do realize that these things are edited heavily and that Russell likely made the same statements multiple times during the game. It's a coincidence at best that Tyson voted for Parvarti after Russell said that. If I'm remembering correctly, the vote was to go 3-3 and whoever didn't play the idol would go home. By Tyson voting for Parvarti she would go home regardless of Russell's vote because it would be 4-2. Russell's vote would have meant 5 votes instead of 4 and wouldn't matter. Even if he never talks to Russell, he likely makes the same stupid decision because he didn't even need Russell's vote and quite honestly, if Russell did actually vote for Parvati it's 4-3 anyways and she goes home.
So, besides telling Russell he was going to make a vote against Parvati that would have been meaningless as soon as Tyson changed his vote what exactly did Russell do?
It was stupidity by Tyson not a great play by Russell.
shakes wrote:
Heroes tell Jeff Probst at the challenge that they believe there is an all girl alliance. Russell uses this knowlege and plays it up at subsequent challenges by exchanging glances with JT. JT uses this info to come up with his plan to give Russel the idol.
So you are saying that is was Russell's goal to get them to give him the idol? Oh my! He sent glances! Every challenge they had people looking at each other and trying to pass messages. Most of these people knew each other from the reunion shows in the past anyways. Stephanie basically said as much. I can't believe you are saying it's a great strategic move by Russell to let the heroes make a wrong guess on something and then give the idol to the enemy. Once again, this was one of the dumbest moves in Survivor history. If you want to talk strategy start talking about Parvarti using two idols to save her alliance or getting Candice to vote with them. Don't mention the dumbest move in Survivor history, at least according to the fan vote.
shakes wrote:
Seriously, are you this stupid on purpose Rick?
No. It's natural. However, I'm not the one giving Russell credit for others making two of the dumbest moves in history. Who gets the credit for James leaving the game with two idols also?
