Curious Hair wrote:
The weird thing isn't that it hasn't really worked for them, because overrelying on veteran signings and trades to buttress a miracle fifth-round pick has yielded about what you'd expect: they finished first in the conference once but mostly live in 9th place. What's weird is that they get wheelbarrows of praise for their brilliant offseasons that amount to nothing while the New York Islanders use about the same strategy (hell, both teams even dinged the Hawks on cap crunches) with about the same results (got in a few times, won a round once, usually miss) but are a laughingstock of the NHL. I suspect it's because there aren't many Stars fans and the ones who do exist spend a lot of time online being witty, while Islanders fans tend to be irascible middle-aged chuds who have to pop blood pressure pills just from thinking about Mike Francesa.
Bowman's Wings used the sign Cup seeking veterans strategy to some success post-2000. Bringing in Brett Hull and Dominik Hasek for a cup in 2002 (Chelios was already there). But then the Wings had one of the best defenseman to ever play the game anchoring their D and they could mix and match scorers in front of him. Yzerman/Federov were a few years further into their careers by that point than Toews/Kane are now. But I wouldn't be surprised if the Bowmans pursue a similar strategy to pick up another Cup or 3 with Toews/Kane.
The current Stars franchise never got their defense properly sorted.