Nardi wrote:
Cashman wrote:
The Hawk wrote:
Nardi wrote:
The Hawk wrote:
Nardi wrote:
If you're going to take Sanchez' job and give it to Moncada based on upside, you better trade Sanchez or else there's going to be a shitload of trouble in the clubhouse. Sanchez has earned his spot, Moncada hasn't earned shit, and everybody in that dugout knows it.
Maybe but as far as I am concerned neither player has earned a spot. Not yet anyway. I think that sometimes you need to throw out the up to the minute "stats" with young players and just look at the tool set that they have. I project Moncada to be a borderline all star down the road. HE just needs to make more contact and figure things out. He is only 23 years old. Most 23 year old players are at double A, not getting their experience in the bigs.
Among 3rd Basemen, he ranks 11th defensively and 17th offensively. So yeah, he's earned it. He's a bonafide starting 3rd Baseman. Has been since he took over at 3rd. We'd all like better, but don't shit on him with this bullshit "utility man" stuff.
[sarcasm]But his WAR![/sarcasm]
I just disagree. 3rd base is a power position. They need a power able person to fill it. Its like the argument about our catching. It sucks over-all as a position also. Sanchez is one of those guys on most teams who can make the team as a 23rd to 25th player for a couple of years but in no way is your starter long term.
That's fine. But your suggestion was handing a .395 slugging 2nd baseman 3B is also kinda funny.
I don't think your opinion is in any way funny. Don't get me wrong. We are just talking about a couple of young baseball players. We both may be wrong or right.
I am just projecting what I feel is the make-up of Moncada's tool set. I like his swing for starters. I like his power from the left side. I like his age and the fact that he now has faced two years of major league pitching. He has good speed although that will diminish as he gets bigger.
With Moncada, the book is still out, in fact it has only started. Typically a prospect like him is only at 2A. HE may not make it. But based on what I see, I think that he will be an all-star in a couple of years.