Buehrle has all the extras on his resume a pitcher could want with the no hitter, perfect game, World Series win and save, etc.

I think the most obvious missing piece is a Cy Young. In fact, he was in the top 5 of Cy Young voting only once, which illustrates why he isn't a HOF player.

he was not drunk for his save. He had 2 beers

_________________
O judgment! Thou art fled to brutish beasts,
And men have lost their reason.

Some homer claims there, but interesting nonetheless.

Buehrle had stretches when he was just awful, too.

_________________

Had he hung on a couple more years, which he could have, maybe he's borderline. As is, nah.

Agree.

I don't think either 56 or 14 cared. When they were done, they were done.

_________________

I think that pretty well sums it up. He had about as cool of a non Hall of Fame career as it was possible to have, but I never thought I was watching a dominant pitcher who was an all time great.

Konerko and Buehrle.

All Time franchise greats that deserved whatever local accolades they get or will get, including their numbers being retired. Overall very, very good players, but not HOF worthy. Close and perhaps in the discussion, but not quite there.

_________________

This is 100% correct. I feel the same about Baines though.

_________________
“Mr. Trump is unfit for our nation’s highest office.”- JD Vance
“My god, what an !diot.”- JD Vance tweet on Trump
“I’m a ‘Never Trump’ guy”- JD Vance

Baines was head and shoulders above Paulie as a hitter. If Baines didnt play in such cavernous ballparks, their career home run totals probably would have been similar.

The veterans committee has definitely watered down Cooperstown more than anybody else though

_________________

And if Baines didn't play in the modern dead ball era. I don't think people understand that the game was different before the strike. Baines led the league in slugging one year at about .545

_________________