This Ends in Antioch wrote:
One Post wrote:
This Ends in Antioch wrote:
Isn’t one of the players’ main issues that some owners intentionally field uncompetitive rosters? Why not provide incentives to make them field more competitive rosters?
More playoff teams will do the exact opposite. Why spend the money to win 95 games and make the playoffs when you can field a team of cheap shitbums and have a coin flip shot at making the playoffs.
To stop teams from fielding intentionally uncompetitive rosters you have to disincentive that behavior, which right now there are very few. Losing spots in the draft, losing international spending money, and most importantly losing revenue sharing. Implement some form of all three and you’ll see teams like the Orioles sign viable free agents right fucking quick.
I disagree obviously. The team that spends today to win 95 games in an attempt to win the WS isn’t going to stop spending in hopes they can achieve the same goal at a lower cost. Not without massive collusion at least.
Would ownership sign off on eliminating revenue sharing or would that be like asking the players for a hard cap?
We aren’t talking about teams like the Dodgers or Yankees. Those teams will always spend money. The players aren’t pissed about teams like those. The teams are pissed about those teams that essentially say they have the talent to win 82 games, and if they get lucky they will win 86 games and that is enough to make the playoffs. So why spend $40 more million to guarantee 90 wins when it isn’t that much more valuable than the coin flip shot at 86 wins.
The middle class teams that already cheap out to squeak into the playoffs are going to spend less if you expand the playoffs. These teams are who the players are pissed at. The players don’t want expanded playoffs because they know that the already cheap owners will spend even less, have less incentive to promote MLB ready talent, etc.
The issue with expanded playoffs isn’t that the top 5 spending teams are all the sudden going to spend like the Cleveland Guardians. Anyone who thinks that is clueless. The problem is with expanded playoffs, the Cleveland Guardians have even more incentive to run cheap shitbums out there because there are even more slots to make the postseason with mediocre talent.