Nas wrote:
Clawmaster wrote:
Nas wrote:
Purdy has an idea where he's going with the ball before the snap. I saw him somewhat rattled in the Browns game, but he was still able to put the 49ers in position to win the game with 3rd and 4th string guys.
Do you think another HC could coach up Fields to the point that he could be more efficient in the passing game, because sticking with him frees you up to pick some high-end talent in the draft, adding Harrison Jr. and a franchise LT almost QB proofs the offense.
Williams is interesting because he can make some off platform yet accurate throws, and does have the ability to throw guys open, a strong HC like Harbaugh could maybe get the best out of him, so do you go with the ability and hope he grows up under a quality HC?
Maye looks to be more of a long-term project, but it a bit bigger, seems to have more leadership traits and could be outstanding in an NFL pocket passing system, can you ride out a year of growing pains with him?
I think a better coach could have helped Fields develop into a better player if that coach were present in Year 1. We're approaching Year 4. I believe it's too much of a high risk gamble to stick with Fields if the Bears have the 1st or 2nd pick in the draft.
The NFL has a way of humbling a lot of quarterbacks. If you already have shitty intangibles, I don't think they improve at the NFL level. I don't think I could draft Williams #1. There's a chance he could be a bust if he goes to a team like the Patriots.
Maye has spent his college career playing with mostly mediocre to AWFUL talent. I think that's a positive heading to the next level. He's used to being uncomfortable. Plus, the Bears would have better talent than he's ever played with if they made zero improvements. I think this kid is the perfect quarterback to build with.
If you take Maye at #1 it would be tempting to trade the second first round pick, but only move down a few slots, depends on where you finish, if your still top 4 you could trade back to six or seven, pick up an extra pick and still maybe get the ND LT, Bowers, D lineman, or a WR.
Like the idea of giving a rook QB either a franchise LT, WR, or TE he can grow with, plus adding a stud LT and signing a vet C gives you a quality O line for the next several years. Could easily turn Whitehair and Eddie Jackson's cap room into a top FA center, and you getting by cheap with your LT, RT, and QB on rookie deals.
There seems to be a good group of WR's this year, so might be able to move back to ten and still get a solid prospect.